Skip to main content

The content below has been generated by an AI model. If anything is unclear, check the source document (opens in new tab) .

Proposed Fisheries Management Measures for Inshore Marine Protected Areas and Proposed Priority Marine Feature Management Areas

Item: 1

Enterprise and Infrastructure Committee: 10 November 2026

Report by Director of Infrastructure and Organisational Development.

1. Overview

1.1. This report seeks delegation to submit a Council response on the Marine Directorate of the Scottish Government consultation on Proposed Fisheries Management Measures for Inshore Marine Protected Areas and Proposed Priority Marine Feature Management Areas.

1.2. The consultation opened on 14 September 2026 and closes on 18 January 2027.

1.3. Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) are sites containing habitats and species of national or international conservation importance.

1.4. Priority Marine Features (PMFs) are a prioritised list of habitats and species of conservation importance in Scotland’s seas used to help focus conservation action and decision making in marine planning.

1.5. The proposed fisheries management measures include options to restrict the use of specific fishing gear that can adversely impact protected features within MPAs (e.g. hydraulic dredge fishing) and measures to close PMF management areas to mobile bottom contacting fishing gear (e.g. scallop dredging) that can adversely impact these features.

1.6. Fishing methods that do not adversely affect MPA features or PMFs would not be affected by the proposed fisheries management measures, for example creel fishing and scallop diving.

1.7. There are proposed fisheries management measures for 11 existing MPAs and nine PMF management areas in the Orkney marine region that are included in the consultation, as detailed at Appendix 1.

IMAGE: The document page displays the Orkney Islands Council crest and wordmark alongside the report title and the opening section, “1. Overview”.

1.8. The proposed fisheries management measures have been prepared by the Scottish Government through a process of engagement with stakeholders including the fishing industry, local authorities and environmental bodies.

1.9. Draft documents provide the rationale for the proposed fisheries management measures, as well as assessments of the potential impacts and benefits of these measures.

1.10. The Marine Planning team has and will continue to work closely with the Orkney Fisheries Association and Orkney Regional Inshore Fisheries Group to inform the preparation of a Council response to the consultation.

1.11. Due to the timescale constraints to respond to the consultation, the complexity of the consultation information and the need for detailed engagement with the local fishing industry, it is proposed that authority is delegated to the Director of Infrastructure and Organisational Development, in consultation with the Chair and Vice Chair of this Committee, to submit a Council response to the consultation by the submission deadline.

1.12. It is proposed that the Council response to the consultation be prepared in accordance with the principles detailed in section 4.3 in this report.

2. Recommendations

2.1. It is recommended that members of the Committee:

  1. Note that the Marine Directorate of the Scottish Government has issued a consultation on Proposed Fisheries Management Measures for Inshore Marine Protected Areas and Proposed Priority Marine Feature Management Areas, for which responses are due by 18 January 2027.

  2. Note the principles outlined in section 4.3 of this report, which are proposed to form the basis of the Council’s response.

  3. Delegate powers to the Director of Infrastructure and Organisational Development, in consultation with the Leader, Depute Leader and Chair and Vice Chair of the Enterprise and Infrastructure Committee, to submit a response, based on the principles outlined in section 4.3 of this report, on behalf of the Council, to the Marine Directorate of the Scottish Government’s consultation on Proposed Fisheries Management Measures for Inshore Marine Protected Areas and Proposed Priority Marine Feature Management Areas by the deadline of 18 January 2027.

3. Background

3.1. The Marine Directorate of the Scottish Government is undertaking a consultation on Proposed Fisheries Management Measures for Inshore MPAs and PMF management areas. The consultation opened on 14 September 2026 and closes on 18 January 2027.

3.2. The consultation considers proposed fisheries management options which have been developed for 76 existing MPAs, and 90 PMF management areas within the Scottish inshore region. No new MPAs are proposed as part of this consultation. There are fisheries management measures proposed within 11 existing MPAs, and nine PMF management areas in the Orkney marine region, as detailed at Appendix 1. The proposed fisheries management measures include management options to restrict the use of specific fishing gear that can adversely impact MPA protected features (e.g. hydraulic dredge) and management options to close PMF management areas to mobile bottom contacting fishing gear (e.g. scallop dredging).

3.3. The Scottish Government is seeking views on the proposed fisheries management measure options, their potential impacts and whether there are additional considerations that should be taken into account before any decisions are reached by Scottish Ministers. It is stated that decision making will be informed by the best available evidence, local knowledge and stakeholder experience.

3.4. The proposed fisheries management consultation is supported by a suite of socio-economic, environmental, fisheries and island communities impact assessments:

  • Strategic Environmental Assessment - Environmental Report (SEA);
  • Social and Economic Impact Assessment (SEIA);
  • Sustainability Appraisal Report (SA);
  • Partial Business Regulatory Impact Assessment (BRIA);
  • Partial Island Communities Impact Assessment (ICIA);
  • Social Impacts Research Report and
  • Draft Fisheries Assessments.

4. Council Consultation Response

4.1. The Scottish Government and NatureScot have engaged with the Council and Orkney fishing interests on the emerging fisheries management proposals since 2022, including an Elected Member Seminar in October 2025.

4.2. The Council’s Marine Planning team has and will continue to work closely with representatives of the local fishing industry, including the Orkney Fisheries Association and Orkney Regional Inshore Fisheries Group, to seek feedback on the proposed fisheries management measures, associated social and economic impacts and any wider effects on the local fishing industry. This feedback will inform the drafting of the Council response to the consultation to ensure that the views of the local fishing industry are understood and appropriately addressed.

4.3. It is proposed that a Council response to the consultation be prepared in accordance with the following principles:

  • Officers will continue to work in close collaboration with the Orkney Fisheries Association and Orkney Regional Inshore Fisheries Group to understand the issues for the local fishing industry resulting from the consultation.
  • The Council response will prioritise measures which will sustain Orkney’s sustainable fishing industry and measures that enable thriving local fishing communities.
  • The Council response will prioritise measures which will avoid significant adverse socio-economic impacts on Orkney fishing communities and identify relevant measures to avoid, minimise or mitigate adverse impacts of the local fishing industry.
  • The Council response will support fisheries management options that maximise sustainable fishing opportunities whilst providing sufficient and proportionate protection for marine environmental features and the ecosystem services they provide.

4.4. The Council response will seek to ensure that any future changes or further policy development by the Scottish Government is undertaken with sufficient levels of pre-engagement and consultation with the local fishing industry, and Orkney Community.

4.5. The SEIA identifies a total value of landings from vessels and fishing gear types in the Orkney Islands marine region as £25 million per year. The proposed fisheries management measures are estimated to affect total landings by a reduction of up to 0.1% i.e. a reduction of up to £25,000 in annual landings. There are no predicted employment losses in Orkney, with most restrictions targeting gears currently absent from the Orkney sites.

For Further Information please contact:

James Green, Team Manager (Marine Planning), extension 2516, Email james.green@orkney.gov.uk

Implications of Report

  1. Financial: There are no direct financial implications resulting from the recommendations in this report, with the preparation of the Council response to the consultation being resourced from within the existing Planning Service budget.

  2. Legal: Public authorities have duties in respect of MPAs pursuant to sections 82 and 83 of the Marine (Scotland) Act 2010 in relation to exercising functions to support the furtherance of MPA conservation objectives and in relation to activities which pose a significant risk of hindering the achievement of those objectives. Special Areas of Conservation and Special Protection Areas (European marine sites), which are designated under the Conservation (Natural Habitats, &c.) Regulations 1994 or the Conservation of Offshore Marine Habitats and Species Regulations 2017 are also subject to duties. Together, these legal frameworks establish a duty for public authorities to implement and enforce appropriate management measures for MPAs. Under section 15 of the Marine (Scotland) Act 2010, public authorities have certain duties in relation to marine plans and how they are to be taken into account in decision making. For the proposed PMF management areas, National Marine Plan states that “development and use of the marine environment must not result in significant impact on the national status of Priority Marine Features.” Following the conclusion of the consultation process, Scottish Ministers will decide upon the appropriate fisheries management measures to take forward. Legislative mechanisms to implement fisheries management measures may include orders under the Inshore Fishing (Scotland) Act 1984 and the Sea Fish (Conservation) Act 1967. Responding to the consultation provides the Council with an opportunity to make representations as to manageable scope and impact of such measures.

  3. Corporate Governance: None directly related to the recommendations in this report.

  4. Human Resources: None directly related to the recommendations in this report.

  5. Equalities: None directly related to the recommendations in this report.

  6. Island Communities Impact: Scottish Ministers will need to take account of their duties under the Islands (Scotland) Act 2018 when making their decision on the proposed fisheries management measures. An Island Communities Impact Assessment has been completed by the Scottish Government and will inform Scottish Ministers decision making on these matters.

  7. Links to Council Plan: The proposals in this report support and contribute to improved outcomes for communities as outlined in the following Council Plan strategic priorities:

  • ☒ Growing our economy.
  • ☒ Strengthening our Communities.
  • ☐ Developing our Infrastructure.
  • ☐ Transforming our Council.
  1. Links to Local Outcomes Improvement Plan: The proposals in this report support and contribute to improved outcomes for communities as outlined in the following Local Outcomes Improvement Plan priorities:
  • ☐ Cost of Living.
  • ☒ Sustainable Development.
  • ☐ Local Equality.
  • ☐ Improving Population Health.
  1. Environmental and Climate Risk: A Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) Environmental Report has been prepared by the Scottish Government and deposited for consultation alongside the fisheries management measures consultation paper. The SEA assesses any significant environmental effects associated with these proposed measures including climate benefits, risks and impacts.

  2. Risk: There is potential for the proposed fisheries management measures to have significant socio-economic impacts on Orkney communities. Any identified risks will need to be understood from the perspective of the local fishing industry to inform the Council response to the consultation.

  3. Procurement: None directly related to the recommendations in this report.

  4. Health and Safety: None directly related to the recommendations in this report.

  5. Property and Assets: None directly related to the recommendations in this report.

  6. Information Technology: None directly related to the recommendations in this report.

  7. Cost of Living: None directly related to the recommendations in this report.

List of Background Papers

Consultation paper and supporting documents – https://consult.gov.scot/marine-scotland/fisheries-management-measures-for-inshore-mpas/

Appendix

Appendix 1: Marine Protected Areas and Priority Marine Feature Management Areas with proposed fisheries management measures in the Orkney Islands marine region.

Appendix 1: Marine Protected Areas and Priority Marine Feature Management Areas with proposed fisheries management measures in the Orkney Islands marine region

Abbreviations

  • NCMPA: Nature Conservation Marine Protected Area
  • SAC: Special Area of Conservation
  • SPA: Special Protection Area
  • PMF: Priority Marine Features

Marine Protected Areas (Sites)

  • Calf of Eday SPA
  • Copinsay SPA
  • Faray and Holm of Faray SAC
  • Hoy SPA
  • Marwick Head SPA
  • North Orkney SPA
  • Papa Westray NCMPA
  • Rousay SPA
  • Scapa Flow SPA
  • Sule Skerry and Sule Stack SPA
  • West Westray SPA

PMF Management Areas (Areas)

  • Bay of Tuquoy, Westray
  • Bay of Swartmill, Westray
  • Copinsay
  • Hoy Sound (East) to South Walls
  • Hoy Sound
  • Eday, Sanday, and Stronsay
  • Orkney Sounds and Firths
  • Papa Westray, South
  • Widewall Bay

Map 1: Sites and areas in Orkney Islands marine region

IMAGE: Map of the Orkney Islands marine region showing the sites and areas covered by the proposed fisheries management measures, including proposed Priority Marine Feature Management Areas, Nature Conservation Marine Protected Areas, Marine Special Protection Areas and Special Areas of Conservation. It marks Orkney Islands, Kirkwall, Scapa Flow, Hoy, Copinsay, Papa Westray, Rousay, Westray, Eday, Faray and Holm of Faray, Sule Skerry and Sule Stack, North Caithness Cliffs and Scrabster. The legend also identifies ports, the Scottish zone, the territorial limit (12 nautical miles), Scottish and offshore marine regions, and the region of interest. Scale bar: 0–50 km.